Shopify vs Etsy-which one is Better for your Print on Demand Business

Shopify logo and Etsy logo with a cart in it.

Unleash Your Online Store’s Potential: Comparing Shopify and Etsy to Find the Perfect Platform for Your Business!

Wellcome millionaires in the world of e-commerce. Last stop for your every query choosing the best Ecommerce platform. Choosing the right platform to showcase and sell your products is crucial for the success of your online business. Shopify and Etsy are two popular options with their strengths and features. Both Esty and Shopify have some pros and cons. In this blog post, We are comparing two big platforms Shopify and Etsy. To help you make an informed decision for your online store business. So, let’s weigh the pros and cons of each platform. For this reason it is easier for you to determine which platform is better suited to meet your specific needs.

Shopify vs Etsy comparison

AspectShopifyEtsy
Ease of setup✔️✔️
Free trial✔️✔️
Customizability✔️
Hosting✔️✔️
Custom Domain✔️
Transaction fees✔️
Marketplace presence✔️
Marketing features✔️
Brand control✔️
Inventory management✔️
Seller community✔️
Lower subscription plan✔️
Lower transaction fee✔️
Better customer support✔️

Key differences between Shopify and Etsy

AspectShopifyEtsy
Platform PurposeE-commerce platform designed for creating and managing online storesOnline marketplace focused on selling handmade, vintage, and craft items
Pricing or PlanPer month
Basic plan $25USD
Small Business $65USD
Advanced $399USD
Free or $10 per month
Free trialExtendable 14 day trial period30 day free Etsy plus trial period
PaymentShopify Payments take 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction.Etsy payments take 3% + 25¢. you can use PayPal or Stripe for lower payment fees.
Flexibility Yes No
Customer Supportvery friendly Live chat, call and email supportOnly email support
Inventory Managementstrong inventory management tools and integrationsBasic inventory management features
Additional Features Apps can run your store automaticallyBuilt-in tools no apps or plugins
MarketingYou have run adsexisting marketplace
Marketing toolsOffers built-in marketing tools, SEO features, and integration optionsLimited marketing tools and reliance on Etsy’s marketplace visibility
Making BrandAllows you to brand yourselfDose not allow
ScalabilitySuitable for both small and large businessesPrimarily caters to small and independent sellers
Shop customizationYes drag and dropNone

Shopify

Shopify is a leading e-commerce platform that provides an all-in-one solution for building and running an online store. With the help of Shopify, you have complete control over your website, branding, and product offerings. 

Shopify is one of the best online store builders with over 6 Million e-commerce sites built with Shopify. Online sellers from over 175 countries using Shopify around the world.

AMAZON HANDMADE VS ETSY-PROS AND CONS-WHICH IS BETTER

How to set up a Shopify Store?

Setting up a store on Shopify is straightforward. It’s like drag and drop. Shopify offers a user-friendly website builder. Enabling you to easily design and customize your online store without the need for coding skills.

The best part of Shopify free trial period is that you can chat with a Shopify representative and extend your 14 day trial period for more 10 days.  You can have a custom domain which builds the customer trust for you. You can choose from numerous professionally designed templates. Easily edit or design them by your need. Shopify provides a range of pricing plans making it a flexible choice for entrepreneurs and established businesses. After setting up your store you don’t need approval from Shopify to start selling.

Etsy

product listed on Etsy

If you are a designer and good in handmade, vintage, or craft supplies. Are you Looking for an e-commerce platform with low startup cost? Starting your online store business without spending a penny on marketing advertisements then Etsy is the best platform for you. Etsy offers a ready-made audience of customers who appreciate and seek out unique items.

How to set up an Etsy Store?

Setting up a shop on Etsy is relatively quick and easy. You can showcase your products, create engaging listings, and benefit from Etsy’s built-in audience. Etsy has leverage for its existing traffic, potentially increasing your visibility and sales. You might get a sale on your first day. Etsy also provides tools and resources to help sellers succeed, including forums and educational materials.

Comparing fees and Pricing structure

When it comes to fees and pricing, both Shopify and Etsy have their respective structures.

Shopify’s Plans

Shopify offers $1 for 3 months on all the subscription plans. Shopify operates on a subscription-based model, offering different plans at varying prices. The fees and pricing of Shopify depend on the features and level of support you require. Shopify allows you to choose a subscription plan that aligns with your business’s needs, providing flexibility as your store grows. Shopify’s transaction fees decrease as you move to higher-tier subscription plans or use Shopify Payments.

Shopify Plan Comparison

Etsy Plans

Etsy charges no monthly subscription fee for you to make your online store. Etsy has a $10 subscription fee plan for more options. Etsy charges a small amount of fees for listing items and transactional commissions. You pay a small fee per listing, giving the exposure of your product on the platform. You have to pay 20¢ on every listing that expires after every four months.
While these fees may seem reasonable for individual sellers or small businesses, they can add up if you have high sales volumes.

Comparing Tools and Features

Both Shopify and Etsy offer a range of tools and features to help your business.

Shopify’s key features

Shopify boasts an extensive app store, allowing you to integrate various third-party
apps and services. These apps offer so many additional functionalities such as inventory management, marketing automation, social media integration, and much more. These apps help you to automate your online store so you can take care of other things. With Shopify, you have the freedom to customize your store and expand its capabilities as your business evolves.

Etsy key features

Etsy provides built-in tools tailored to its marketplace, focusing on connecting sellers with potential customers. You can optimize your listings with detailed descriptions, high-quality images, and relevant tags to increase the chance of discoverability. Etsy has a seller dashboard that offers valuable insights and analytics to help you track your store’s performance. Therefore you will be able to make better decisions.

Taxes and Legal Considerations

Running an online store business involves financial responsibilities and legal considerations.

Shopify’s Tax solution

Shopify provides various tools and apps to help you manage taxes and comply with legal requirements. The platform connects you with popular accounting software and offers features like tax calculators, invoicing, and financial reporting. Shopify also provides guidance on common legal matters.

Etsy Tax solution

As an Etsy seller, you are responsible for understanding and complying with the tax regulations in your authority. Etsy sellers take care of the tax and legal situations by themselves. Etsy does not help you with tax or legal obligations. You can consult with a tax professional or seek legal advice to ensure you meet all legal obligations and maintain accurate financial records.

Which Platform is Right for You?

Choosing between Shopify and Etsy ultimately depends on your specific business needs, goals, and preferences. Consider the following factors when making your decision:

  1. Product Type: If you offer handmade, vintage, or craft supplies, and want to tap into a niche market, Etsy may be the ideal platform.
  2. Branding and Control: If you value complete control over your store’s design, branding, and customer experience, Shopify is the best option for you. Shopify provides the flexibility and customization options.
  3. Scalability: If you are planning to expand your product offerings, Shopify’s scalability and advanced features make it a suitable choice.
  4. Financial Considerations: Analyze the fees, pricing and transaction fees structures of both platform.
  5. Marketplace vs Standalone Store: Consider whether you prefer to leverage an existing marketplace (Etsy) or build your own brand and drive traffic to your standalone website (Shopify).

Conclusion

In the Shopify vs. Etsy debate, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Both platforms have their strengths and cater to different types of businesses. Shopify empowers you to build a unique online store with full control over branding and scalability, while Etsy offers a ready-made marketplace with a niche audience. Evaluate your specific requirements, long-term goals, and budget to make an informed decision that aligns with your vision and business strategy.

Whichever platform you choose, remember that investing time and effort into building your online store is a crucial step towards establishing a successful and thriving e-commerce business.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top